Discussion about this post

User's avatar
DrBDH's avatar

The Trump administration has blocked worldwide use of Anthropic’s most advanced products. In return, French and German security services are switching from Palantir. The threat of American AI being turned off for Europe is spawning a movement away from US tech, another blow to the big AI companies’ plans to dominate the workplace. There is also European distrust of bros like Alex Karp, Musk and Altman embracing Trump. And then there’s the rise of at-home AIs that aren’t connected to the internet, making the big data servers unnecessary.

blake harper's avatar

This is good. Some of the research cited is a bit out of date, but improved results won’t shift the underlying fundamentals.

The only piece of the story you haven’t added here is on the margin compression dynamics that open source introduce. The blitz scale plan could only work with Uber and AirBnB because there aren’t good, cheap substitutes so that had monopoly pricing power. That’s not at all true for LLM inference.

If the business and consumer demand that actually IS there flows increasingly towards on-device and open source, the revenue for frontier labs ins going to collapse.

So even IF the models were reliable, they’d still face this commodification dynamic. We’d end up with massive surplus value not capturable in rents. In the actual world, we’ll end up with modest value creation (lower than the internet… maybe comparable to cloud infra), but where most of that is just surplus.

The only hope the labs have is that they can convince their investors that they’re on the way to RSI and then AGI. This has become a fully messianic fantasy. When reading today’s bullish punditry look at the proportion of the discussion focused on present value v speculative future value. These bulls have been fully magic-pilled because they WANT to believe.

5 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?